November is here and that means that holiday baking is right around the corner. Krystina Castella, offers some wonderful tips on how to keep your baking at it’s best!

10 Cookie Troubleshooting Solutions
1. The bottoms burn while the tops are not yet cooked: You need an insulator. Use an insulted baking pan or parchment paper, or stack two pans together to create a double layer. Make sure the cookie sheet is placed in the middle of the oven.
2. Cookies are too flat: Too-soft butter was the most likely culprit. Next time, refrigerate the dough for 20 to 30 minutes before baking.
3. Cookies look fine in the oven but flatten out when removed: Too much air was beaten into the dough while creaming. Don’t worry; they will still taste good.
4. Rolled-cookie dough is too sticky to roll: Remember that the dough will also pick up flour from the work surface and rolling pin. If that won’t be enough, chill the dough for 1 hour and see whether that helps. If not, then add a bit more flour to reach the desired consistency.

5. Cookies are too hard: Soften in an airtight container with a piece of bread or fresh sliced apple. The cookies will absorb the moisture.
6. Cookies are overbaked: Make small test batches. Prepare 4 or 5 cookies at the preheated temperature and test the dough consistency and baking times. Adjust for the full batches.
7. Cookies are too dry and crumbly: This is something you can observe when the dough is prepared. There might be too much flour or too little liquid or shortening in the dough. Don’t pack the flour in the measuring cups. If you have this problem in the dough again, add more butter or a few tablespoons of milk next time.

8. Sides of the cookies fuse together: Leave more space between them on the pans: 1 inch for cutout cookies, at least 2 inches for drop cookies. No harm will be done if you leave more space than you think you need.
9. Cookies stick to the cookie sheet: The cookie sheet was not adequately greased or the cookies were left on the sheet to cool too long. Next time use parchment paper or grease. For now, reheat the cookies at the recipe baking temperature for 2 to 3 minutes and remove.
10. Cookies baked unevenly: The dough is not thoroughly mixed, the cookies are different sizes, or there are hot spots in the oven. Mix dough thoroughly, make cookies the same size, and rotate sheets in the oven.
Thank you so much for these great tips Krystina!! Be sure to check out Krystina’s new book that was just released yesterday, Crazy About Cakes, for more great recipes and baking tips!
You Might Also Like: